A Brief Analysis of the Judgment in Women's Legal Centre Trust v President of the Republic of South Africa 2022 5 SA 323 (CC)

Abstract

On 28 June 2022 the apex or Constitutional Court (CC) handed down a much-awaited judgment which impacts upon Muslim marriages  concluded purely in terms of Islamic law in South Africa. Does the judgment mean that such Muslim marriages are now fully recognised  for all purposes in the South African legal context? The simple answer is "no". The rationale for this conclusion is to be found in the two- pronged judgment. The first part of the judgment is wholly suspended and will only and automatically come into effect if remedial  legislation is not enacted in 24 months. The second part of the judgment pertains to an interim order which takes effect immediately and  applies retrospectively to all Muslim marriages that subsisted on 15 December 2014 (when the case was first launched by the Women's  Legal Centre in the Western Cape High Court) and to Muslim marriages which, although terminated before that date, were still subject to  ongoing legal proceedings at that date. While the case note briefly refers to the first part of the judgment, the main purpose of this case  note is to highlight some of the practical problems that could be encountered by couples when effect is given to the orders pertaining to  the interim relief granted in terms of the second part of the judgment. The problem areas are highlighted by looking at the CC judgment  in the light of three fictitious scenarios. The case note provides a few critical comments on the judgment and ends with a few concluding  remarks. Past experience leads us to expect that tangible progress will take place only by 2024, a date which coincides with South Africa's  next presidential election. Until then the non-recognition of Muslim marriages will continue to prove burdensome to Muslim women and  children.