A photo-identification-based assessment model of southern right whales surveyed in South African waters, with a focus on recent low counts of mothers with calves

Abstract

Photo-identification data for southern right whale cow–calf pairs on the South African calving grounds provide one of the longest abundance time-series  for any whale population worldwide. Following a very steady increase from a heavily depleted state, surveys since 2015 reflect many notably low counts.  These data are analysed to investigate whether these low counts can be explained by changes in reproduction-related parameters. This necessitates a modification to an earlier reproduction model for these whales, fit to photo-identification data to allow for early abortions; hence, a whale pregnant one  year can again be pregnant the next. This can account for an increase in calving intervals in a way that differs from a whale resting for another year or an  increase in late-abortion probability. This modification was able to account for the low number of sightings of cow–calf pairs over the 2015 to 2020 period  (excepting for 2018), though the estimated probability of sighting a cow–calf pair in 2018 is somewhat low given a nearly unchanged annual  survey effort. Hence, low numbers of sightings of females with calves for five of the years from 2015 to 2020 can be explained by changes in  reproduction-related parameters rather than an increased natural mortality which is inconsistent with the photo-identification data. Changing  environmental (particularly feeding) conditions seems to be the likely cause, possibly associated with a changed distribution of these whales. The  estimated number of all whales in the population in 2020 is 6 470 (SE 285), with the number of parous females estimated to have increased 15-fold over  the last four decades.